A recent event that has our country
up in arms and the government scrambling for support is the death, no, murder
of the beloved gorilla Harambe. For those of you who aren’t entirely clear
about the story of Harambe, here is a brief explanation. Harambe was a gorilla
who lived in the Cincinnati Zoo. He was fatally shot after he was deemed a
threat to a three-year-old boy fell into his habitat. This situation has raised
protests from several different groups. The loudest and most vigilant group has
been the animal rights activists, who argue that the shooting of Harambe was
completely uncalled for and another solution could’ve been brought about by other
means. A second group has been putting heat on the Cincinnati Zoo for housing
Harambe in an inadequate habitat, allowing for such a situation to arise. A
third group has been pointing fingers at the parents, saying that they are
guilty of neglecting their child; how else could a three-year-old find his way
into the habitat of a gorilla?
This brings me to my topic for the week: Harambe memes and their effect on all of us. I have found all of these memes to be especially hilarious, as all memes typically are. I think that the Harambe memes resonates specifically with Freud’s take on the relief theory. Freud suggests that humor is caused from societal tension and repression, resulting in the release of nervous energy. The relief theory allows for us to be able to laugh at the memes and, indirectly, at the death of this poor gorilla because of the building tension in the country. The population is able to laugh in order to distance themselves from the real problem: animal cruelty.
The
premature humor that the memes have been able to conjure makes me think that
maybe there is a taste of underlying incongruity theory in the memes. Hutcheson’s
incongruity theory places two unlike metaphors beside each other and the
contrast between the two provides a shock factor. I think that the shock factor
in the memes comes from the contrast between the serious pictures of Harambe
beside a humorous phrase that doesn’t directly go with the picture.
My question is this: How did we get
to a point where we are able to laugh at the unlawful and violent death of an
innocent animal? I admit that I’ve at least chuckled at every Harambe meme I’ve
seen. But with this humor shouldn’t there be a pang of guilt? This seems like a
good example of how we’ve become desensitized to certain types of inappropriate
humor. I know that this is getting a little deep about meme about a gorilla,
but I think that it is able to accurately represent how comedy has really just
spiraled down a hole. A hole where, at the bottom, there is vulgarity and overriding
desensitization.



I think you are right that there is something about Harambe memes that are just kind of on this side of horrifying, which allows them to be funny instead. There are countless variations on the Harambe meme, and all of them seem to skirt to the edge of some trauma. Here one of the main considerations perhaps is the close relationship between humans and other great apes--there is even a movement to extend legal protections akin to those offered to people to other members of the hominid family. The final meme is another interesting case--I'm pretty certain that it was created with racist intent (people comparing gorillas to african americans, and implying that the concern for their lives is on part with concern for apes, etc.), but it is just ambiguous enough that it could be innocent. It could just be an attempt to appropriate the slogan for a different purpose, with no intended negative comparison. What do others think?
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree that the final meme I added is opening a whole other can of worms as far as memes go. At first glance, I didn't even second guess the meaning because well, Harambe is a black gorilla. However after I added it to my rough draft, I began to notice the racial undertones that accompany the meme. The more I researched and brainstormed about these Harambe memes and jokes, the more I began to feel a mix of guilt and outrage. How could a society so bent on political correctness seem so desensitized to (a) the murder of an endangered species and (b) the continual racial undertones that are accompanying many of the Harambe memes.
DeleteWell, I think you make a great point that political correctness can, at its worst, represent a second best gesture, a consolation prize when actual change is not pursued. It's easy to miss all the nuances because the memes are so adaptable.
Delete